The Price Is Right In Fantasy Football Rookie Drafts

Recently, 12 members of the Fantasy Life team (myself included) wrapped up our rookie draft for a superflex dynasty league.

All things considered, it's a pretty sharp group so it made for an enjoyable draft that included several trades and a few surprising picks. Let's break down Round 1.

Round 1 of the Dynasty Life Rookie Draft

1.01 - Jeremiyah Love

It's hard to argue with this one. Even in superflex formats, it's either Love or the next guy I'll highlight.

1.02 - Fernando Mendoza

You'll be hard-pressed to find a superflex draft that doesn't have these two at/near the top of the board. Positional scarcity necessitates snagging Mendoza here unless you truly have two elite QBs already.

1.03 - Jadarian Price

This is where the fun started. Our own Stefano Vaccarino traded up from the 1.04 to the 1.03 to draft Price. Here are the specifics of trade:

Stefano Vaccarino

• Sent - Dalton Kincaid, 2026 1.04
• Received - 2026 1.03, 2027 2nd Round Pick

Jorge Martin

• Sent - 2026 1.03, 2027 2nd Round Pick
• Received - Dalton Kincaid, 2026 1.04

While it's clear that Stefano wanted Price, I'm a bit surprised he moved up to get him since he was already sitting at the 1.04. Regardless, I'm always in favor of going to get your guy.

1.04 - Jordyn Tyson

Jorge moved back one spot and selected Tyson. I'm curious how managers are going to approach this tier of top-3 wideouts. FTR, Jorge later admitted that he had intended to take Price, even at the 1.03, because of an RB need. So the consolation was Tyson. Don’t feel sorry for him.

1.05 - Carnell Tate

Landing Tate here feels like a bit of a value and I love it. We project him to lead the Titans in targets this season and finish just shy of 200 PPR points. The Ohio State wideout factory rolls on.

1.06 - Makai Lemon

This Lemon pick represents the biggest tier break in Round 1 for me. If you're looking at how to approach your rookie draft, the 1.06 is the last of the premium picks. I have no problem (somewhat) mixing up the order of the top six picks, but there's certainly a difference after this.

1.07 - KC Concepcion

This was my pick. As mentioned, this slot is the top of the next tier. I considered trying to trade back a few slots, but decided to just roll with what I had and dip into the next tier of wideouts led by Concepcion.

1.08 - Kenyon Sadiq

The consensus rookie TE1, Sadiq has a chance to make an impact in Year 1. We'll see if Geno Smith is able to support multiple fantasy-viable assets this season.

1.09 - Omar Cooper

Speaking of rookie players on the Jets, Cooper brings National Championship experience and a solid profile to a team desperate for more help on offense.

1.10 - Eli Stowers

Gene Clemons drafted Stowers as the TE2 (and second Eagle) taken in this draft. Stowers is perfectly lined up to be the heir-apparent in Philly, as Dallas Goedert enters the final year of his contract.

1.11 - Chris Bell

If there's an offense with a ton of opportunity for an incoming wideout, it's Miami. Bell has all the talent in the world, but needs to get fully healthy after he tore his ACL last November.

1.12 - Denzel Boston

Oh hey, our own cooterdoodle picked last. That must mean … oh, wait. Yeah, she kinda dominated last year. We'll see if she reads this. Anyway, it feels different seeing two Browns players go in Round 1. Hopefully one of them can make an impact right away. No matter what the league charter allows.

Join Our Newsletter

Trusted by 400,000+ fantasy football players. Get access to Fantasy Life's free award winning newsletter and tools, all in one step.

Email Address

Subscribe

By registering or logging in, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Love is in the Air

Can Jordan Love get back to the way we were in 2023? Here’s Ian’s breakdown.

Jacobs Still a Bell Cow?

Josh Jacobs has been the focus on the Packers’ offense for two seasons. Ian looks at the Green Bay RB room.

GB WRs Narrow Focus

With fewer mouths to feed, will the Packers WRs be better for fantasy? Enjoy Ian’s analysis.

Premium

Go FantasyLife+

Your league is unique. Your advice should be too. Get personalized tools, rankings, and projections tailored to your fantasy football league settings.

Learn More